Call: 1-877-697-2926

Want a Path to Cheaper Internet? Stop Renting Your Equipment (2025)

Buried in your monthly internet bill is a charge that rarely gets questioned—equipment rental fees. Over time, this unassuming cost adds up, quietly inflating your expenses by $10 to $15 every month. That’s potentially <$180 a year> for a modem you don’t own. A growing number of customers are rethinking this model, rejecting provider-issued gear in favor of owning their own hardware. The reason is simple: cutting costs without sacrificing performance. This article breaks down how eliminating rental fees leads to real savings, while maintaining the connection speeds you expect.

Where Your Money Goes: Understanding ISP Equipment Rental Fees

What Does “Equipment Rental” Really Mean?

When signing up for internet service, the provider usually offers to supply you with a modem, router, or a gateway device—sometimes all three. These devices connect your home to the internet, but they don't come free. Instead, they’re leased to you through a monthly rental model.

Modem: Connects directly to your internet service and acts as a bridge between your home and the ISP's network. Router: Distributes internet access wirelessly across your devices within the home. Gateway: A single device that combines a modem and a router.

The Monthly Cost Adds Up

ISPs typically charge anywhere from $10 to $20 per month for equipment rental. Over a single year, that adds an additional $120 to $240 to your baseline internet cost. Multiply that by three or more years of service, and you’re looking at significant cumulative expenses.

How These Fees Show Up on Your Bill

Most providers don't bundle equipment costs into the base service price. Instead, a separate line item appears on your bill every month—usually labeled as “Equipment Fee” or “Gateway Rental.” This pricing structure gives the illusion of a lower base rate while pushing the real cost higher through add-ons.

What Are You Actually Paying For?

The monthly fee covers the physical device, firmware updates, and minimal technical support. However, not all ISPs offer support beyond basic troubleshooting. Don’t expect premium features or the latest hardware technology—rented devices are often entry or mid-tier models deployed in volume.

Are Rental Fees Optional or Mandatory?

Reviewing the provider’s fine print is the only way to uncover whether these fees are avoidable or hidden under bundled costs.

Renting vs. Buying: Let’s Compare

When Renting Might Work—for Now

Start with the upsides. Renting equipment from your internet service provider (ISP) involves zero upfront cost and minimal decision-making. Just plug it in and go. If the modem fails or the router stops broadcasting Wi-Fi, your provider typically replaces it without hassle. Tech support already knows the hardware configuration, so diagnostics and troubleshooting calls are straightforward.

Some rental agreements even include automatic upgrades. When your ISP rolls out new hardware, renters may be eligible for upgrades—though this often varies by provider and contract. Renting feels easy because the systems are already integrated and pre-tested for compatibility with your specific service package.

But Convenience Isn’t Free—Or Flexible

ISPs charge a recurring fee for that convenience. In the U.S., the average monthly rental fee sits between $10 and $15, according to Consumer Reports. Over five years, that totals $600 to $900 for a piece of hardware worth a fraction of that price. And that doesn’t even consider the performance limitations.

ISPs don't always offer the latest technology to renters. You might be paying monthly for a gateway that doesn’t support dual-band Wi-Fi or lacks DOCSIS 3.1 support—both of which impact speed and stability. Firmware updates are slow to roll out, feature controls are restricted, and configuration options are limited or locked.

Buying Once, Owning for Good

Buying a modem and router comes with an upfront cost, but that investment pays off within one to two years. A high-performance modem/router combo might cost $120 to $200. Compare that to five years of rental fees, and the savings are obvious.

Even modest routers and modems from trusted brands like Motorola, Netgear, or TP-Link can keep up with gigabit speeds. Most models stay relevant for at least 5 years, and firmware updates are manufacturer-supported.

You’ll Pay More for Not Owning

Delayed upgrades hold renters back. For example, if your ISP rolls out multi-gigabit service but your rented modem only supports DOCSIS 3.0, you won’t benefit without a hardware upgrade—and ISPs don’t always upgrade renters right away.

Rented units may also block advanced features like bridge mode, limiting compatibility with modern mesh systems. Without hardware ownership, you sacrifice potential improvements in latency, range, and device prioritization. That’s the hidden cost: cash wasted on outdated equipment that bottlenecks your network.

The Real Cost Behind "Convenient" Equipment Rentals

$15 doesn’t sound like much—until it's $180 a year. Stay with that same provider for three years and the total hits $540. That’s what millions of households unknowingly spend just to rent the modem and router sitting in the corner, quietly blinking away.

Compare that to the cost of ownership. A high-quality modem-router combo that supports gigabit speeds and dual-band Wi-Fi typically costs under $150. Popular models like the Motorola MG7700 or Netgear Nighthawk CAX30 regularly fall within this price range. One-time purchase, long-term use.

From Monthly Drains to Annual Gains

The math adds up quickly, but the value doesn’t. Unlike a smartphone or computer, rental routers and modems rarely receive upgrades during your contract. Some ISPs even install equipment with limited features, constrained Wi-Fi range, or reduced speed thresholds.

Real Customers, Real Savings

Consider Gina from Portland. She spent $139 on a Netgear CM1100 modem and a TP-Link Archer AX1800 router—fully compatible with her Xfinity plan. Her setup paid for itself in just over 9 months. Since then, her internet bill has remained $15 lower every month.

Then there's Jamal in Chicago. He calculated over $600 in rental fees across 42 months with his ISP. After switching to his own ARRIS SURFboard combo unit, not only did the hardware pay off within a year, but he also reported fewer service calls and consistent speeds across his 1,400-square-foot apartment.

Every month you continue to rent, you're increasing your sunk cost without gaining ownership. Shift the equation: invest once, save indefinitely.

Buying Your Own Modem or Router: What You Need to Know

Understanding the Difference: Modem, Router, or Combo?

Start with the basics. A modem connects your home network to the internet through your Internet Service Provider (ISP). A router distributes that internet connection to devices inside your home wirelessly or through Ethernet cables. A modem-router combo does both jobs in a single unit. Each option has trade-offs in terms of flexibility, upgradeability, and performance. Choosing separate devices typically allows for better customization and long-term scalability, while combo units save space and reduce setup complexity.

Factors to Consider Before You Buy

Performance Features That Make a Difference

Top-Rated Devices by Budget

Here’s a curated selection based on performance, value, and user reviews across verified platforms:

Modern hardware delivers better throughput, longer lifespan, and fewer security vulnerabilities. Stop paying monthly for outdated equipment and take control of your home network today.

Will It Work? Checking Compatibility With Your ISP

Before buying a modem or router, confirmation of compatibility with your Internet Service Provider (ISP) eliminates guesswork. Each ISP maintains a list of approved devices rigorously tested for performance and configuration compatibility, and these lists vary by speed tier and service type.

Find Official Compatibility Lists From Major ISPs

How to Verify Your Modem or Router Works With Your Service

Start by identifying your internet plan’s speed tier—information typically available in your account details or monthly bill. Once you know your plan speed, match it with a modem that supports at least that level of throughput. Many ISPs break compatibility lists down by speed range, showing which models are optimized for each tier. Choosing a device certified for your speed ensures full utilization of your bandwidth.

Also note the technology type your service uses—DOCSIS 3.1 for cable, for example, or GPON for fiber. For cable connections, DOCSIS 3.0 may suffice for speeds under 500 Mbps, but DOCSIS 3.1 provides better downstream capacity and future-proofs the setup.

Common Compatibility Issues (and How to Dodge Them)

Once you've selected a model, contact your ISP to confirm compatibility, especially if your provider requires device registration. Some services allow self-activation, while others require a call to customer support to provision the new device properly.

The Setup Process: Easier Than You Think

Step-by-Step: Installing Your Own Modem and Router

Replacing your rented equipment doesn’t require a background in IT. Most users complete the setup in under 30 minutes, including activation and testing. Here’s how to do it:

Activating Your Equipment With the ISP

After physical installation, your ISP needs to link your new modem to your account. Many ISPs offer self-activation portals:

If the provider lacks a self-service portal, a direct call to customer support will do the job. Be ready with your modem’s MAC address, usually printed on the box or bottom of the unit.

What If Something Goes Wrong? Try This

Even with a smooth setup, things can occasionally stall. These steps resolve most first-time installation issues:

Major ISPs support customer-owned devices through web, app, and phone channels. Expect fully staffed technical support lines, often 24/7, even for users who bring their own equipment.

What Are Your Rights? ISP Policies on Using Your Own Internet Equipment

Can Your ISP Legally Require Equipment Rental?

ISPs in the United States cannot legally force customers to rent routers or modems as a condition for service. The Television Viewer Protection Act of 2019, which took effect on December 20, 2020, blocks broadband providers from charging rental fees for equipment customers already own. This regulation prohibits “junk fees” that appear on bills even when you use your own hardware.

In practice, this means your internet provider has to offer you the option to use a compatible third-party device without charging you for equipment you aren't using. If a fee still shows up, that violates federal law. Simply put, the law backs your right to stop renting and use your own device without penalty.

FCC Rulings That Support Consumer Equipment Choice

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) strengthened consumer rights through regulations designed to increase transparency and eliminate anti-competitive practices. Applying to ISPs across the board, these rules clarify your right to use compatible third-party modems and routers.

The FCC mandates that providers must publish a list of approved compatible equipment models. This prevents ISPs from withholding technical requirements or hiding behind proprietary standards. Any device that meets the published requirements must be allowed on the network. Providers can test and approve devices for network compatibility, but they can’t reject your equipment without valid technical reasons.

How ISPs Attempt to Discourage Equipment Ownership

While ISPs legally can't mandate equipment rental, some continue tactics that discourage ownership:

Here’s how to respond: request the official equipment compatibility list. Confirm your device is on it or meets the published specs. Document any fees that appear after removing rented equipment, and reference the 2019 federal law. If push comes to shove, file a complaint with the FCC Consumer Complaint Center.

Don’t let ambiguity block your path to lower internet bills. You have the right to own your equipment—and avoid monthly rental charges while still enjoying full access to service.

Want a Path to Cheaper Internet? Stop Renting Your Equipment—and See the Performance Boost

Speed Isn’t Just a Number—It’s an Experience

Most internet service providers offer basic, all-purpose modems and routers on rent. These devices often support older Wi-Fi standards like 802.11n or low-end 802.11ac, which cap out at theoretical speeds far below what many home networks demand today. By contrast, mid-range consumer-owned routers support newer protocols like Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax), delivering higher throughput, lower latency, and improved simultaneous device handling.

Consider this: Wi-Fi 6 supports speeds up to 9.6 Gbps, significantly outperforming Wi-Fi 5 (3.5 Gbps) and Wi-Fi 4 (600 Mbps). If you're on a 500 Mbps plan, a rented router running an outdated standard can bottleneck your entire service. An owned device with more processing power and advanced antenna arrays eliminates that risk.

Coverage That Reaches Further and Stays Strong

Rented routers frequently fall short in larger homes. Their internal antennas and underpowered chipsets limit effective range and strength through walls or floors. When you purchase your own router—especially mesh networking systems—you gain access to intelligent signal steering, beamforming, and multiple access points working in unison.

Features You Actually Control

Rented equipment locks users into limited configuration interfaces, often hidden behind ISP dashboards. With owned gear, features become fully accessible. Here's what's unlocked:

These features make a difference, especially in households with high data demands or children needing carefully managed access.

The Real-World Shift: From Lag to Lightning Fast

Households often report immediate returns after switching to better personal equipment. In a Reddit thread on r/HomeNetworking with over 4,000 upvotes, users shared side-by-side results. One user on a 300 Mbps Comcast plan saw Wi-Fi speeds jump from 80 Mbps to 280 Mbps simply by replacing the wired-only ISP modem with a DOCSIS 3.1-compatible Netgear CM2000 and pairing it with an ASUS AX3000 router.

Another anecdote comes from a small office: employees complained about dropped Zoom calls and sluggish cloud services. After replacing the ISP's standard router with a UniFi Dream Machine, both connection stability and speed tests showed marked gains across every department.

Selecting the right hardware, and owning it, opens the door to higher throughput, stronger wireless consistency, and more advanced tools than any rented device will ever deliver. Ready to measure your network against what’s possible?

The Long-Term Savings of Buying Your Own Equipment

From Cost to Value: When the Numbers Turn in Your Favor

Most ISPs charge between $10 and $15 per month to rent equipment. Over 12 months, that adds up to $120–$180. Multiply that over three years, and you're paying $360–$540 for hardware worth far less. Mid-range modems and routers typically cost between $100 and $200 combined. The financial breakeven point usually hits by month 10 to 15. After that, every month you use your own gear represents pure savings.

For example: Buy a $160 modem-router combo that’s certified for use with your ISP. If your previous rental was $14 a month, you'll break even after 11.4 months. Starting in month 12, you pocket that $14 every cycle. Over the next two years, that’s $336 saved — and that’s just on rental fees.

Performance Upside: What You Don't Get From ISP Rentals

Beyond dollars, owning delivers real performance advantages.

Over three to five years, these incremental benefits create a smoother, more reliable online experience — a dimension most pay-per-month rentals can't offer.

Looking Ahead: Choosing Equipment That Pays Off for Years

Future-proofing starts with knowing where tech is headed. Look for these three attributes in any new device:

Purchasing with a 3- to 5-year timeline in mind guarantees not just cost savings, but sustained performance as networks evolve. Want a path to cheaper internet? Stop renting and start investing — the payoff’s measurable and visible every billing cycle.