Internet articles

AT&T Sues Comcast Over 'Fiber-Powered' Internet Ads

Updated

A coaxial cable and an orange fiber conduit enter an unmarked utility box on the side of a house
AI-generated editorial image of generic home wiring; not a specific Comcast, Xfinity or AT&T installation.

AT&T has sued Comcast over the way Xfinity advertises its residential internet and Wi-Fi as "Fiber-Powered." The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, says that claim gives reasonable customers the misleading impression that Xfinity Internet is a fiber-to-the-home service comparable to AT&T Fiber. In fact, AT&T argues, most Xfinity Internet runs over a hybrid fiber-coaxial network, with copper coaxial cable covering the last mile to the home.

This is a lawsuit, not a court decision. Comcast has not been found liable in this case, and the company can dispute AT&T's reading of the ads. The filing asks for a permanent injunction that would stop Comcast from describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as "Fiber-Powered," and for Comcast to give up profits AT&T says were earned from the advertising.

What AT&T says is misleading

AT&T argues that phrases such as "Fiber-Powered," "Powered by fiber," and "the most reliable, fiber-powered Wi-Fi" are literally false, or false by necessary implication, when they are used for a network that does not run fiber all the way to the home. The complaint also says that even if a court does not treat the wording as literally false, it is still misleading if it leads a substantial share of reasonable customers to believe the connection into the house is fiber alone.

The difference matters in everyday use. Fiber to the home can offer symmetrical upload and download speeds. A hybrid fiber-coaxial, or cable, connection typically has a much slower upload speed than download speed. For a plain-language comparison of those technologies, see our shopper guide to Xfinity "fiber-powered" service versus real fiber. Confirm the technology at your exact address, because Comcast also offers fiber-to-the-home in some locations.

The earlier advertising review, and the Charter case

AT&T previously challenged Comcast's fiber-powered claims through the National Advertising Division, an advertising-industry self-regulatory forum. In June, the NAD said Comcast accurately described its mix of cable and fiber technology in a disclosure, but that the disclosure was not prominent enough. It recommended placing the coaxial-cable disclosure closer to the "fiber-powered" claim. Comcast said it would comply. AT&T's new lawsuit shows it is not satisfied with the current advertising.

This Comcast case follows a similar AT&T lawsuit against Charter over Spectrum "fiber-powered" advertising, filed in August in the Northern District of Texas. Charter has asked that court to dismiss the case, arguing that "fiber-powered" fairly describes the role fiber plays in a hybrid network and that its disclosures are adequate. We covered that filing in AT&T vs. Charter: the fiber-powered advertising lawsuit. Neither case, on its own, changes the plan you have today.

If you are shopping for service, look past the label. Check the Broadband Facts label, advertised upload and download speeds, and whether a technician would install a cable modem or a fiber optical network terminal at your home.

Compare the internet technology actually offered at your address

A marketing label is not the same as fiber to the home. Enter your ZIP code to see which providers are listed at your address, then confirm speeds, uploads and connection type before you switch.

Check providers by ZIP Call 1-877-697-2926

Frequently asked questions

Did a court rule that Comcast's fiber-powered ads are false?

No. AT&T has filed a lawsuit in the Northern District of California. That is an allegation, not a finding that the advertising is unlawful.

Is Xfinity Internet fiber to the home?

In most of Comcast's footprint, residential Xfinity Internet uses a hybrid fiber-coaxial network, with coaxial cable for the last connection to the house. Comcast also offers fiber-to-the-home in some locations. Confirm the technology at your address.

What is AT&T asking the court to do?

The complaint asks for a permanent injunction stopping Comcast from describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as Fiber-Powered, and for Comcast to give up profits AT&T says came from the advertising.

Is this the same case as AT&T's lawsuit against Charter?

No. The Charter case was filed earlier in the Northern District of Texas and involves Spectrum advertising. The legal theory is similar, but it is a separate lawsuit.

Related RSINC guides